The approach that will be used here, which is sometimes called the capability approach, sees human life as a set of doings and beingswe may call them functioningsand it relates the evaluation of the quality of life to the assessment of the capability to function. It is argued that the capability approach can reflect the many ways that human lives are blighted and that it thus offers a promising framework for poverty analysis. Amartya sen s capability approach available for download and read online in other formats. To influence these, it retains some of their assumptions, and appears limited by its conceptions of the person and of agency. Sens capability approach provides an invaluable analytical and philosophical foundation for those interested in pursuing development as freedom, but it is a foundation that must be built on, not just admired. The book has an introductory chapter, followed by 2 parts, and a brief appendix that looks at some of sens formalized relationships and proposes various amendments to these. Amartya sens capability approach theoretical insights. It proposes that social arrangements should be primarily evaluated according to the extent of freedom people. Sens capability approach does not explicitly allow that formal education may not. Are liberated companies a concrete application of sens.
The capability approach focuses on what people are able to do and be, as opposed to what they have, or how they feel. Sugden cites nussbaums work as evidence in making his case. The first section outlines the main components of the capability approach. This compelling book introduces nobel laureate amartya sen s capability approach and explores its significance for theory, policy and practice in education. Amartya sens capability approach as theoretical foundation of human development published in journal of sociology and development article pdf available march 2018 with 10,222 reads. Sens capability approach, often to the effect of showing that such criticisms are misplaced if not mistaken. Sen argues that, in analysing wellbeing, we should shift our focus from the means of living, such as income, to the actual opportunities a person has. Sen deliberately left the capability approach incomplete in order to ensure its relevance to persons and cultures with different understandings of the good. Amartya sens economic and political theory including, centrally, his work on the idea of human capability as both a goal of and an indicator of development has had a major impact on both the theory and practice of international development and won him, among many honours, the. The approach that will be used here, which is sometimes called the capability approach, sees human life as a set of. Pdf amartya sen s capability approach download full. Amartya sens capability approach the capability approach also known as the capabilities approach is a theoretical and normative framework concerned with. The second adapts the capability approach to the elaboration of a. This article examines the underexplored relationship between amartya sens capability approach to human well.
Added to this viewpoint, is the perspective of education as a right, which highlights its intrinsic value. Sens most important critique on rawlsian justice concerns the inflexibility of social primary goods as the metric of justice. Sens capability approach as a framework to the practice of. The capability approach stanford encyclopedia of philosophy. Amartya sen has developed the socalled capability approach to meet the criticism that income alone may be insufficient. The methodology of public scrutiny draws on rawlsian understanding of objectivity in ethics, but the impartiality that is needed cannot be confined within the borders of a nation. Collective capabilities, culture, and amartya sens. This essay is concerned with the analysis of the foundational concepts at work within sen and nussbaums cas. Sens discomfort with utilitarianism as a metric for discussion on social justice spells a need to explore alternative criteria for the evaluation of social states9.
This paper suggests that incorporating amartya sens capability approach when assessing higher education provides a broader, multicriteria framework that answers the need for a normative ideal. Contributors hail from the uk, usa, australia, italy and mexico. Another approach is to consider its capability, in terms of the freedom and ability of people to achieve. Sens capability approach signals a major event in recent thinking on welfare economics. Poverty as severe capability deprivation amartya sen and the evolution of the concept of poverty leland joseph r. Nussbaums work, on the other hand, has been of considerable interest.
This article explores the key ideas in the capability approach of. Sens capability approach internet encyclopedia of philosophy. Some refelctions 2016 human development report office 2 think piece s. The capability approach can be applied at two distinct levels of evaluation namely, a assessment of an individuals wellbeing or more generally her advantage encompassing both wellbeing and agency and b assessment of the goodness of a social action or a social arrangement. Sen argues that economic development should expand valuable capabilities. Aug 28, 2011 development as freedom amartya sen first anchor books edition, random house,inc. In comparing sens work with mills, sugden criticizes sens capability approach because it may be applied in such a way that society or theorists judge what is best for people and potentially restrict liberty on that basis. Sixth, a capability theory of justice needs to specify where the line between individual and collective responsibility is drawn, or how it will be decided, and by whom, where this line will be drawn. Its development, critiques and recent advances by david a. Sens idea of justice 2009 moves beyond capability approach which articulated the space in which to evaluate wellbeing, and towards a welfare economics, with multiple dimensions in capability space, as well as principles, and processes. However, if there is general agreement in the first place that such capabilities should be equally guaranteed for all, there is a clear basis for criticizing clearly unjust social norms as the source of relative deprivation and thus as inconsistent with. Amartya sens capability approach and social justice in. The capability approach ca, developed by amartya sen, martha nussbaum and other social theorists is a broad, humancentred normative framework for the evaluation of individual and group wellbeing, quality of life and social justice.
Development in practice sens capability approach as a. This chapter reconsiders the differences between amartya sens capability approach and john rawlss justice as fairness approach. The capability approach has obvious relevance for social policy, though it was never intended to guide policy design. Essays on amartya sens capability approach repub, erasmus. Individualism sens emphasis on individual effective freedom as the focal concern of the capability approach has been criticized as excessively individualistic.
Thecapabilityapproachempowermentandparticipation download thecapabilityapproachempowermentandparticipation ebook pdf or read online books in pdf, epub, and mobi format. The author examines how amartya sens capability approach can be coherentlyand practicallyput to work in participatory poverty reduction activities so that the voices and values of the poor matter. However, human rights to important process freedoms cannot be adequately analysed within the capability framework. Sen describes it as representing the various combinations of functionings beings. Sen s capability approach is a helpful intervention in the discourses of mainstream western welfare economics and moral philosophy. Pdf amartya sens capability approach alik naha academia. It originated in amartya sens disquiet with orthodox welfare economics based on utility maximisation and his desire to focus on the potential to do things and choose ones own lifestyle sen 1982, 1985, 1993. Download pdf amartya sen s capability approach book full free. Recently, there has been a growing interest in empirical studies based on sens capability approach. Critical social policy and the capability approach on jstor. The capability approach has been advanced in somewhat different directions by martha nussbaum, who has used the capability approach as the foundation for a partial theory of justice. The success of a country can be measured by such as gross national product gnp per capita, health of its people, education levels and so on. Rawls has argued that this critique implies that the capability approach endorses a comprehensive moral doctrine. But one particular issue in the philosophical approach to sens writing on the capability approach bears mentioning earlier because it relates to the approach i have taken in this thesis.
The capability approach ca developed by amartya sen focuses on the enhancement of peoples capabilities, i. Sens capability approach as a framework to the practice of development capability approach, in order to contribute to articulating a development approach that radicalises the practice of development. This compelling book introduces nobel laureate amartya sens capability approach and explores its significance for theory, policy and practice in education. Sens capability approach as a framework to the practice of development alexandre apsan frediani online publication date. Pdf amartya sen s capability approach download full pdf. The presence and importance of the capability approach in sen s work is thus undeniable, but should not be seen as the only defining feature. Sens capability approach as a framework to the practice. Sen argues that an individuals welfare should not be measured in terms of her income, but in terms what she can actually do or be, her capabilities. Amartya sens capability approach theoretical insights and. Sens capability approach sage journals sage publications. An introduction to the capability approach master hdfs. Amartya sen had an extensive background in development economics, social choice theory. Pdf amartya sens capability approach as theoretical. Sens work has tended to be used in general discussions of policy and critiques of theories regarding education and the economy.
Sens capability approach and nussbaums capabilities. Sen is not a capability theorist ftp directory listing cnrs. Abstract the human capabilities approach developed by the economist amartya sen links development, quality of life and freedom. Pdf amartya sens capability approach as theoretical foundation. A discussion of key features of the capability approach the capability approach is a theoretical framework that puts emphasis on the importance of freedom to achieve wellbeing, where freedom to achieve wellbeing is understood in terms of peoples. The book looks particularly at questions concerning the education of children, gender equality, and higher education. Pdf sens capability approach to welfare economics ingrid. Part one concerns the key concepts of empowerment at work in sens ca and has three goals. Pdf on mar 31, 2018, shija kuhumba and others published amartya sens capability approach as theoretical foundation of human. By so doing and this is a point that needs emphasising it does not, strictly speaking, provide a complete view. In the first part, it gives a detailed explanation of the capability approach. Sens capability approach is a helpful intervention in the discourses of mainstream western. With his intellectual leadership in developing the human development index1 and, subsequently, the publication of freedom as development2, the capability approach show.
Sens capability approach has been enormously influential, and has been taken up. In this approach, amartya sen and martha nussbaum bring together a range of ideas that were previously excluded from or inadequately formulated in traditional approaches to the economics of welfare. In this text we will take sens capability approach as our starting point, and discuss nussbaums work when it criticises, divers from, or adds to sens work. Is school education always beneficial to an individuals overall capabilities in life. Clark over the last decade amartya sens capability approach ca has emerged as the leading alternative to standard economic frameworks for thinking about poverty, inequality and human development generally. It then considers how these ideas relate specifically to education, before arguing that. The capability approach, then, holds that capabilities are the relevant standard of advantage. Sen and nussbaums ideas have influenced global, national and local policy, such as the annual human development reports of the united nations development. Capability approach pioneered by amartya sen has been a new milestone for analyzing poverty through gender perspective. Sens main response to such criticisms has been to admit that the capability approach is not a theory of justice but rather an approach to the evaluation of effective freedom. Sen argues that an individuals welfare should not be measured in terms of her income, but in terms.
Sen and nussbaums ideas have influenced global, national and local policy, such as the annual human. The paper assesses sens more abstract version of capabilities theory, nussbaums more substantive aristotelian version and attempts to apply such conceptions to womens lives. In comparing sen s work with mill s, sugden criticizes sen s capability approach because it may be applied in such a way that society or theorists judge what is best for people and potentially restrict liberty on that basis. Sens and nussbaums extensive writings on the capability approach may. But the reader who looks for a fully formulated account of social justice generally, and gender justice in particular, in sens work will not find one. The capability approach and education elaine unterhalter, rosie vaughan and melanie walker. Capability approach and individualism because the capability approach lays great stress on the importance of individual choice and freedom, there has been some suggestions that the approach is too individualistic in the sense that it ignores the social milieu which shapes individual lives. Justice as fairness and the capability approach oxford.
He obtained a phd in economics from the london school of economics and worked at the bangladesh institute of development. Friendship, knowledge of foreign groups, the ability to purchase milk and shoes, the scent of summer roses. Furthermore, both human rights and capabilities have to depend on the process of public reasoning. The fourth section relates the capability approach to models of disability and the fifth section.
The capability approach also referred to as the capabilities approach is an economic theory conceived in the 1980s as an alternative approach to welfare economics. Thinking about the capability approach opens a space in which we can be critical of school processes within a normative framework with a sense of universality. Sugdens critique of the capability approach utilitas. Within moral and political philosophy, the capability approach has in recent. The capability approach and human development ophi. Applying the ca to the organizational context, the focus of human resource management is transformed, shifting away from the needs of the organization to the freedoms of the individual. Osmani is professor of development economics at ulster university, uk. The capability approach only identifies such capability failures and diagnoses their causes. The capability approach is the crystallisation of sens deep engagement with welfare economics and ethics. Sens capability approach and nussbaums capabilities ethic. Click download or read online button to thecapabilityapproachempowermentandparticipation book pdf for free now. Development as freedom amartya sen first anchor books edition, random house,inc.
Jun 20, 2014 the capability approach ca, developed by amartya sen, martha nussbaum and other social theorists is a broad, humancentred normative framework for the evaluation of individual and group wellbeing, quality of life and social justice. Understanding the terms of the capability approach. I determine that the capability approach offers a more complete and therefore, superior concept of empowerment. Since the introduction of the approach, numerous scholars from various. Kuklys examines how nobel prizewinning economist amartya sens approach to welfare measurement can be put in practice for poverty and inequality measurement in affluent societies such as the uk.
Sugden cites nussbaum s work as evidence in making his case. Aug 17, 2006 there are many human rights that can be seen as rights to particular capabilities. Why the capability approach journal of human development. Amartya sens capability approach is increasingly influential in the literature of development economics.
1107 58 1449 1198 800 779 757 1308 1227 695 102 921 1280 1087 419 772 1482 464 103 806 140 901 409 1209 1308 421 1424 1478 733 1030 1346 1471 713 863 848 957 1111